Estimated Read Time: 6 minutes
If you’re searching for how to leave insurance as a healthcare practitioner, chances are the model you’re currently working inside no longer feels aligned. You may still love your patients. You may believe deeply in the kind of care you provide. And yet, something about the insurance system feels increasingly restrictive, exhausting, and disconnected from the outcomes you actually want to help people achieve. That tension is what brings many practitioners to this crossroads. You can be full of passion and skills to be successful, but the growing realization that the insurance model wasn’t built to support personalized, preventative, or transformative care can be very disheartening. As a former brick & mortar Primary Care Provider, I know this personally. I spent years practicing inside the insurance model and while I gained invaluable clinical experience, I also experienced firsthand how limiting the model can be…for practitioners and patients alike.
Why the Insurance Model Wears Practitioners Down
For many healthcare practitioners, insurance starts out feeling like a necessary structure. It promises accessibility for patients and stability for providers. Over time, though, the reality often looks very different.
Insurance dictates how care is delivered, how long you can spend with someone, which services are “allowed,” and how much your time is worth. Clinical decisions become filtered through coding requirements, medical necessity rules, and reimbursement negotiations rather than what is actually best for the person in front of you.
I still remember a moment early in my career when an insurance company retroactively denied multiple acupuncture treatments I had already provided (despite proper documentation) forcing me to repay hundreds of dollars for work I had done in good faith. That experience wasn’t an anomaly. It was a wake-up call. Insurance companies are not designed to protect practitioners, and they certainly aren’t designed to prioritize optimal, individualized care.
Over time, this creates a sense of frustration and powerlessness. You know what your patients need, but your hands are tied. Feel rushed. You chart endlessly. You manage conditions rather than addressing root causes. And slowly, the work that once felt meaningful starts to feel draining.
What Patients Are Already Paying (and Not Receiving)
One of the biggest misconceptions practitioners have when considering how to leave insurance is the fear that patients “won’t pay” for care. The truth is, patients are already paying…often far more than they realize.
Between monthly premiums, deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, many Americans spend well over $10,000 per year on healthcare before meaningful benefits even kick in. And despite that investment, most are still navigating restricted provider networks, denied treatments, short appointments, and a system focused on managing chronic disease rather than preventing or reversing it.
What they are not paying for is truly personalized, comprehensive care. Preventative strategies, functional testing, lifestyle-based interventions, and long-term support are often excluded entirely. When you look at it through this lens, the question shifts. It’s no longer “Will patients pay for cash-based care?” It becomes “What if patients redirected what they’re already spending into care that actually serves them?”
Why Leaving Insurance Doesn’t Mean Abandoning Patients
A common fear among practitioners is that stepping away from insurance means leaving patients behind. In reality, the opposite is often true.
Leaving insurance allows you to move out of a transactional relationship and into a collaborative one. Instead of a third-party corporation dictating care, decisions are made between you and your client based on what will best support their health. This shift invites patients into a more active role in their healing. It creates transparency around pricing, clarity around expectations, and space for a deeper practitioner-client relationship. Rather than rushing through visits to meet volume requirements, you’re able to slow down, listen, and address the full picture.
Patients who choose this model are being invited into a partnership rooted in trust, autonomy, and intentional care.
How to Leave Insurance as a Healthcare Practitioner Without Replacing One Broken Model With Another
When practitioners first leave insurance, many move straight into a fee-for-service model charging hourly rates in exchange for one-off appointments. While this can feel like progress, it often recreates many of the same problems.
Exchanging time for money still caps your income. It still limits the depth of care you can provide. And it often keeps practitioners stuck in a cycle of overworking while underdelivering on long-term outcomes.
This is where burnout quietly creeps back in. Charging more per hour won’t solve the issue. You need to get to the root cause of your practice and build a model that allows for sustained engagement, real accountability, and meaningful transformation.
Reframing Value and High-Ticket Care
High-value care doesn’t mean inflating prices or “charging more just because.” It’s about committing to a deeper level of responsibility for outcomes.
When you offer comprehensive programs rather than isolated sessions, you’re able to support clients through real change. You can assess patterns over time, adjust protocols thoughtfully, and guide people through the full arc of their healing process.
From a practical standpoint, enrolling five to ten aligned clients into a high-touch, high-value program is often far more sustainable than trying to serve dozens of people through fragmented, lower-cost offerings. This is especially true when your audience or referral base is still growing.
For clients who are ready, the investment becomes a reflection of commitment, not a barrier. The people who value this level of care tend to show up differently. They engage more fully, follow through more consistently, and ultimately experience better outcomes.
How to Talk to Clients About the Transition
Understanding how to leave insurance as a healthcare practitioner requires more than a pricing change. One of the most important parts of leaving insurance is education. Patients don’t need to be convinced, you just have to help them understand.
This starts with clear communication about what changes and why. Explain how insurance has limited their care. Share how a cash-based model allows for more time, customization, and collaboration. Paint a picture of what their care could look like without restrictions around medical necessity, visit limits, or predefined treatment pathways.
If you’re early in your transition and don’t yet have a library of testimonials, your own story matters. Nearly every practitioner has a personal healing journey that led them to practice the way they do. Sharing that experience builds trust and relatability.
Ultimately, this shift isn’t about rejecting conventional medicine entirely. Emergency and acute care absolutely have their place. This is for stepping out of a system designed for sick-care management and into one that supports prevention, optimization, and long-term wellbeing.
A Different Way Forward
Leaving insurance is a bold decision, and it’s not one to take lightly. But for many practitioners, it becomes the turning point that restores purpose, autonomy, and sustainability in their work.
If you’re feeling the pull to practice differently, it may be a sign that you’re ready for a model that prioritizes depth over volume and outcomes over restrictions. One that allows you to serve fewer clients more intentionally, without tying your income to endless hours or rigid systems that don’t reflect your expertise.
If you want to see what this kind of practice can actually look like in real life, I walk through the full structure inside a free video training: How Online Practitioners Are Making $10K+ Per Month in Just 10 Hours a Week. In it, I break down the model, the mindset shifts required to leave insurance behind, and how practitioners are building sustainable, cash-based practices without sacrificing quality of care or burning themselves out.
You don’t have to rush this decision. But if the current model no longer fits and you’re actively exploring how to leave insurance as a healthcare practitioner, know that there is another way and it’s one that allows you to practice with integrity, depth, and intention.
Ready to dive deeper into how to leave insurance as a healthcare practitioner? Apply for The WELLth Academy.
About the Author: Michelle Rogers, ND, MSAOM, FDN-P, is a clinical mentor and founder of The WELLthy Woman™ movement. A practicing clinician since 2012, she pivoted to mentoring fellow practitioners in 2019 after experiencing her own transformation from clinic burnout to online business success. She has since guided over 150 health professionals to build profitable online practices using her unique integration of functional medicine expertise and scalable business strategies.
Want more insights on building an authentic, profitable health practice? Join my email list for weekly strategies that honor both your expertise and your energy.
Leave a Reply